HIST 258:
Indian Ocean
Music
William McNeill, Keeping
Together in Time: Dance and Drill in Human History (Cambridge,
MA: Harvard University Press, 1995)
Concept/argument:
"Muscular Bonding" (p. 2): "the euphoric
fellow feeling that prolonged and rhythmic muscular movement arouses among
nearly all participants in such exercises."
-
Corollaries (or derivative arguments) that apply to history
(p. 3):
-
"First, throughout recorded history, moving and singing together
made collective tasks far more efficient." [pyramids, warfare, religion,
even trade]
-
"Second, ... long before written records allowed us to know
anything precise about human behavior, keeping together in time became
important for human evolution, allowing early human groups to increase
their size, enhance their cohesion, and assure survival by improving their
success in guarding territotry, securing food, and nurturing their young."
Key point: Human response to music is visceral
and corporeal, as well as conscious and emotional. It affects our
very bodies. Read "Exploring
the Musical Brain", a recent article in this year's Scientific American.
Music, rhythm, and dance facilitated a group cohesion
that probably predated formal language and was crucial for family, group,
band, clan, tribe, chiefdom, and state success in competition with other
families, groups, bands, clans, tribes, chiefdoms, and states.
Music, rhythm, and dance, by destroying boundaries, helps
turn warriors into soldiers...
-
Subhuza II, Swazi king in 1940s (p. 8): "The warriors
dance and sing at the Incwala [an annual festival] so that they do not
fight, although they are many and from all parts of the country and proud."
When they dance they feel they are one and they can praise each other."
...prepares men for battle...
-
Antonio Herrara, 1519, Tenochtitlan (p. 104): "That night
more than a thousand knights got together in the temple, with great loud
sounds of drums, shrill trumpets, cornets and notched bones.... They
danced nude ... in a circle, holding their hands, in rows and keeping time
to the tune of the musicians and singers."
... counters fatigue, and facilitates development
of endurance and extends warmaking capacity...
-
Maurice de Saxe, Marshal of France, d. 1750 (p. 9):
"Have them march in cadence. There is the whole secret, and it is
the military step of the Romans.... Everyone has seen people dancing
all night. But take a man and make him dance for a quarter of an
hour without music and see if he can bear it.... Movement to music
is natural and automatic. I have often noticed while the drums were
beating for the colors, that all the soldiers marched in cadence without
intention and without realizing it. Nature and instinct did it for
them."
... to the point where the playful aspects of the
dance and the military utility of the game become indistinguishable...
-
Tacitus, on ancient Germans (p. 102): "Naked youths,
who practice the sport, bound in the dance amid swords and lances that
threaten their lives. Experience gives them skill, and skill again
gives them grace; profit and pay are out of the question; however reckless
their pastime, its reward is the pleasure of the spectators."