HIST 258:  Indian Ocean
Fall 2001

NOTE:  This is an Old Syllabus.  If you are looking for the fall 2002 syllabus, click here.
 


Instructor:  Vijay Pinch
Class Hours: Tues and Thurs, 10:30 - 11:50
Office Hours: Tues 2:00-3:30, or by appointment (x2399; wpinch@wesleyan.edu)

This lecture/discussion course surveys the history of southern Asia and the Indian Ocean, with emphasis on the pre-modern era. Topics to be examined include travel and exploration, religious culture, social change, land and sea-based technologies, trade, state formation, and the civilizational encounter with Europe. Readings will combine historical analysis with primary sources - including travel accounts, religious poetry, imperial chronicles, courtly drama, and popular literature.

The following texts are required for the course and are available at Atticus:

Additional documents are available online (underlined with a link in the syllabus below).  Sudents are strongly urged to supplement the readings and lecture/discussion with timely perusals of The Historical Atlas of South Asia [HASA], two editions of which are located in the atlas cases in the reference section of Olin Library.

The grade for the course will be based upon the following (see the schedule of lectures and readings for respective due dates):

Note on the panel discussions:  Students will divide themselves into four groups, each group being responsible for either MISR, IAL, LCC, or SS.  Each group will use their text as the basis for a panel-led class discussion on the dates shown in the syllabus.  Each text should be treated not simply as a work of aesthetic merit, but as a historical document.  In other words, students should glean from the texts details concerning the social, economic, religious, and political world of southern Asia, and how the text reflects the connections of southern Asia to the world beyond its shores.  In addition to the questions noted in the syllabus, the groups should prepare the following to facilitate discussion:
  1. Visual illustrations from the material culture of the period (these may be web-based)
  2. "Social-historical" observations for general discussion -- one per student
All students, in preparing for discussion, should reflect on the ways in which the texts supplement, or correct, the history presented in CHI and/or TCIO (or by the instructor, for that matter).

Note on the Travel/Discovery paper:  Each student will choose, at the beginning of the semester, an original pre-1700 travel account that deals with southern Asia and/or the Indian Ocean.  Choices must be approved by the instructor and finalised by September 14th. (Note:  Marco Polo's travels is off limits.)  For some suggestions click here; also, K. N. Chaudhuri's bibliography contains many possible titles.  Topical themes are listed below. Students must complete the vital statistics and discovery sections; students should choose three of the additional four themes.  There are a range of due date options, listed below; students should present on September 14 their choice of travel account and a formal schedule for submitting the linked essays.

  1. Vital statistics:  This introductory section of the essay will consist of a basic description of the travel account, including the author's identity (and any questions pertaining thereto), the route taken and mode of travel, the circumstances of authorship (why and when and how it was written), the manuscript and publication history, and any noteworthy particulars concerning the editor and/or translator.  Students should also mention remarkable forensic details, such as the quality of the paper and binding, the size of the pages, any special orthographic conventions employed, the existence of illustrations, maps, tables, index, and any other noteworthy physical attributes.  This section should be approximately 500 words and must include a map constructed by the student.  Students should also indicate on a separate sheet the schedule of dates that they will be turning in subsequent work.
  2. Sociality:  Report on the traveler's observations concerning human social relations.  Since different travelers will emphasize different aspects of human behavior, there will be considerable latitude.  Some may focus on social hieararchy, ostracism, and theories of corporeal purity and pollution, whereas others may emphasize gender and sexual mores, whereas others still may be interested in language or household.  Some travelers may take a sensationalist approach simply to compare the people and culture of foreign lands unfavorably with those of his home country.  Others may be more even-handed in their treatment.  The goal for the student is to use the travel account to say something concrete about how humans interacted in the environment encountered by the traveler, despite what may appear to be subjective reporting.  This section should be approximately 750 words.
  3. Economy:  Describe the economic world of the Indian Ocean, or the regional pocket of the Indian Ocean described in the account.  Kinds of questions to be answered include:  What are the goods being produced and traded?  Where does trade occur?  How is it structured (are there specific markets for specific goods, do certain communities control certain commodities, are their overarching political units that superintend trade)?  What is the status of merchants?  How is money organised and transmitted?  (Based on the observations of the traveler, students may wish to focus on one or another of these questions, rather than attempt to answer all of them.)  This section should be approximately 750 words.
  4. Belief:  Describe the deeper mental worlds visited by the traveler.  What did the people encountered think about the nature of the world around them, about creation and their own origins, about ultimate causes, about planes of existence?  Did they believe in supernormal beings, and if so, what forms did they take?  Or did they reject such understandings?  How did the traveler respond to these understandings?  Care should be taken to supplement generic terms, such as "Christian" or "Muslim" or "Hindu" or "Buddhist," with more specific descriptive language.  750 words.
  5. Violence/Warfare/Politics:  How does the account shed light on the ways power was articulated, weapons wielded, and conflicts resolved?  If the author was implicated in warfare and conflict, how might that have informed the account?  Is warfare restricted to particular classes of people?  Does violence have a gender dimension, a "caste" dimension?  What is the level of day-to-day or "routine" violence?  750 words.
  6. Discovery:  Students will follow their own instincts and interests to comment or reflect on the travel account.  This section will serve as a kind of conclusion to the essay, but it should not simply recapitulate what has already been written in previous sections.  Students may wish to comment on the question of travel and "discovery," or explore the motives of the author, or think more broadly about the nature of the Indian Ocean world.  Or something else altogether.  750 words.
  7. Final Draft and Bibliography:  In addition to revising the essays, both in response to the instructor's comments and suggestions as well as to better link the sections together, students should also compile an annotated bibliography of relevant works.  The bibliography should consist of at least three articles from scholarly journals, three scholarly books, and one primary source (that intersects with and in some way sheds light on the account).
Due dates:  choose either I or II, and three from III - VI.  VII and VIII are mandatory. Schedule of Topics and Readings/Links:
 
 
DATE TOPIC READING
Part I: Subcontinental Shifts
4 Sep Beginnings HASA:  I.A.1 - II.1
Continental Drift
Becoming Human
Hominid Journey
6 Sep The rise of agriculture CHI:  1-19
HASA:  II.2 - II.6
11 Sep Indus:  The Unvoiced Civilization Indus Valley Civilization website
Deciphering the Indus Script
13 Sep Arya expansion? CHI:  20-37
HASA:  III.A.1, III.A.2
Strabo's Geography
18 Sep Ancient polities and political theory CHI:  38-50, 124-140 
HASA: III.B.1-4, III.C.1-2, III.D.1-2, IV.1
Kautilya's Arthasastra:  website 1
Kautilya's Arthasastra:  website 2
20 Sep Classical culture:
Sexual, Secular, Sentimental

nb:  SAIOCluster

CHI:  51-59, 162-211
Vatsyayana's Kama Sutra (Richard Burton's translation; see esp. part VI, on courtesans)
Ramayana Tradition
21 Sep, Friday Due date I 10 a.m., history department
25 Sep The Little Clay Cart
Discussion:  The Little Clay Cart is a work written for theatrical performance.  Nevertheless, it offers clues to the mental, social, and physical world of southern Asian.  Perhaps not surprisingly, that world includes merchants and courtesans.  What do we learn about these two social categories in southern Asia culture?
LCC:  entire
27 Sep Music CHI:  212-242
1 Oct, Monday Due date II 10 a.m., history department
2 Oct Religion and philosophy CHI:  60-123
HASA: III.B.5, III.C.4, III.D.3, III.D.5
4 Oct Science and technology CHI:  141-161
9 Oct Speaking of Siva
Discussion:  What is an "ascetic" and how might s/he challenge the social and political order?
SS:  entire
HASA:  IV.4, IV.5
Siva mask: Kulu Valley
11 Oct The Indian expansion
Metropolitan Museum of Art
Cambodia: Angkor Wat
CHI:  425-460
HASA:  III.C.5, III.D.4, III.D.6
12 Oct, Friday Due date III 10 a.m., history department
Part II:  Ocean Currents
16 Oct Fall Break
18 Oct Ships and the sea TCIO:  1-33, 119-159
Periplus of the Erythraean Sea
Ancient navigation
Monsoon patterns
22 Oct, Monday Due date IV 10 a.m., history department
23 Oct The Arab-Islamic expansion TCIO:  34-62
HASA:  IV.3
CHI:  281-293, 461-469
25 Oct The Turko-Mongol expansion CHI:  245-265
HASA:  V.1, V.2, V.3, V.4, V.6
TCIO:  160-182
30 Oct Indo-Persian Timurid cosmopolitanism Francois Bernier
Letter from Jahangir
CHI:  310-333
HASA: VI.A.1-VI.A.5 (except VI.A.4)
Begin reading MISR
1 Nov Hindus and Muslims CHI:  266-280, 294-302, 303-309
HASA:  V.5, VI.A.4
Continue reading MISR
2 Nov, Friday Due date V 10 a.m., history department
6 Nov Madhumalati
Discussion:  Hinduism and Islam are often spoken of as civilizational opposites.  This tendency is propelled, in part, by political ideologies in the present.  How does Madhumalati complicate this bifocal understanding of southern Asian religion?
MISL:  entire
Pythons wreck Manohar's ship
8 Nov The Iberian expansion CHI:  337-347
TCIO:  63-79
HASA: VI.B.1, VI.B.3 
Vasco da Gama
St. Francis Xavier
12 Nov, Monday Due date VI 10 a.m., history department
13 Nov Northern European expansion  TCIO:  80-118, 182-228
HASA:  VI.B.2, VI.B.4, VI.B.5
Thomas Mun
The English East India Company
The Longitude Problem
Play the Longitude game
15 Nov The British Empire CHI:  348-364
HASA:  VII.A.1 to VII.A.6
Robert Clive at Plassey
Robert Clive to Parliament
Edmund Burke to Parliament
20 Nov Orientalism CHI:  470-499
Smithsonian exhibit: Sackler Gallery
Thomas Babington Macaulay
William Bentinck
Mountstuart Elphinstone
21 Nov, Wednesday Due date VII 10 a.m., history department
22 Nov Thanksgiving Break Begin reading IAL
27 Nov Digesting the West (or not) CHI:  365-390, 406-423
HASA:  VII.B.1 to VII.B.3, VIII.C.1
Atlantic Monthly, 1857
29 Nov Rejecting the West (or not) CHI:  391-405
HASA:  VIII.A.2, VIII.C.2 to VIII.C.4
Atlantic Monthly, 1908
B. G. Tilak
M. K. Gandhi
4 Dec In an Antique Land
Discussion:  In an Antique Land is a work of both literature and history.  What is its central historical argument?  What lessons does it hold for the student of the Indian Ocean world? 
IAL:  entire
HASA:  IV.3 and VIII.A.2 are useful
6 Dec Conclusions
10 Dec, Monday Final Draft and Bibliography Due 10 a.m., history department